The Ultimate Guide to Toothpaste


There are many different toothpastes out there. You’ll want to be sure you are choosing the right toothpaste for you or your family. At Clark Family Dental, we want to give you some helpful tips on finding the best toothpaste for your needs.

As your New Albany dentist, we are here to help you pick out the right toothpaste. We have compiled this list of toothpastes and given them a rating based on some factors. There are many factors that go into why you should choose a toothpaste and different patients have different needs. This list will give you a good overview of the best organic and natural toothpastes out there and how well they actually live up to that name.

The toothpastes with a “5 Toothbrush” rating are the best all around. The lower the “toothbrush” rating the less effective the toothbrush is likely to be. These toothpaste guides take into account if the toothpaste is organic, certified, and how much fluoride they contain.

Toothpastes with a “5-Toothbrush Rating”

  • Dr. Bronner’s All-One Toothpaste by Dr. Bronner’s
  • >Happy Teeth Toothpaste Organic by Poofy Organics
  • Mieessence Toothpaste by ONE Group
  • Mint Sweet Orange Toothpaste by Made Simple Skin Care
  • Green People Toothpaste and Green People Toothpaste Kids

Toothpastes with a “4-Toothbrush Rating”

  • Weleda’s Toothpaste
  • Face Natural’s Tooth Cleanser
  • Herbal Choice Mari Natural Tooth Gel by Natural Brands
  • Cinnamon/Peppermint Toothpaste by Krista’s Natural Products
  • Dirty Mouth Primal Toothpowder by Primal Life Organics

Toothpastes with a “3-Toothbrush Rating”

  • Just the Goods Vegan Toothpaste
  • TruthPaste Natural Toothpaste by Diamond Dental System
  • Thieves Toothpaste by Young Living Essential Oils
  • The Peelu Co. Toothpaste
  • Redmond Earthpaste Toothpaste

Toothpastes with a “2-Toothbrush Rating”

  • Dr. Brite
  • Coral White Toothpaste
  • Healing Secrets Toothpaste
  • Lavera Toothpaste
  • David’s Natural Toothpaste

Toothpastes with a “1-Toothbrush Rating”

  • Honest Toothpaste
  • Desert Essence Toothpaste
  • Dr. Sharp Natural Oral Care Toothpaste
  • Cleure Toothpaste
  • Auromere Ayruvedic Herbal Toothpaste

Your New Albany dentist is here to answer any questions you have. We are happy to give specific recommendations for the best toothpaste to fit your teeth and needs. Please contact us with any questions or to schedule an appointment.

Contact Us

To inquire about appointment availability, please fill out the form below. ***If you are having a pain emergency please call our office***

Our Location

Find us on the map

Hours of Operation

Our Regular Schedule


7:00 am-5:00 pm


7:00 am-4:00 pm


10:00 am-6:00 pm


7:00 am-5:00 pm